LJ's Territory expanding into the wasteland that is the Internet
Home | Profile | Guestbook | Reviews | Events | E-mail | Sign In | Sign Out | Edit | Xanga
About this Entry
Posted by: lordjabez

Visit lordjabez's Xanga Site

Original: 1/19/2009 8:59 PM
Views: 175
Comments: 7
eProps: 12

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site


Monday, January 19, 2009

I Need Your Help!

 

I've been listening to Chris Tomlin's version of "O Worship The King" non-stop this evening. It's one of my favorite hymns ever, and I love the energy that Tomlin's arrangement coaxes out of a single chord, not to mention the skillful interplay between the organ, electric guitar, and drum kit. But there's one little piece of it that bugs me. Just one little itty bitty line in the extra chorus he wrote. It just doesn't make any sense. Here's the phrase:

You alone are the matchless King
To You alone be all majesty
Your glories and wonders, what tongue can recite?
You breathe in the air, You shine in the light

It's the phrase "You breathe in the air" that gets to me. What exactly is that supposed to mean? God doesn't breathe air. I can't figure it out. Tomlin is trying to crib from one of the original stanzas, but his attempt at "second person"-izing it falls flat. In my confusion I went back to the original text, and interestingly enough, it makes just about as much sense as the revised version (i.e. not much):

Thy bountiful care, what tongue can recite?
It breathes in the air, it shines in the light;
It streams from the hills, it descends to the plain,
And sweetly distills in the dew and the rain.

I like the imagery a bit here, but still can't figure out the line. How exactly does God's care "breathe in the air"? I think what they're trying to say is that we experience God's care when we inhale a breath of fresh air, but of course that's far from what the line says.

So, in light of my confusion, and in the long and glorious tradition of hymn tweaking, I'm asking for your help in finding a further refinement (or a completely different line) that will 1) fit the theme of the verse, 2) fit the rhythm of Tomlin's chorus, and 3) make more sense than the above. The winning response (as judged by me) will be used in EBC's worship service on the 8th of February. So get cracking, budding songwriters!

Currently
Hymns Ancient and Modern
By Passion
O Worship The King
see related
 Posted 1/19/2009 8:59 PM - 175 Views - 12 eProps - 7 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

7 Comments

Visit OneFlossyChick's Xanga Site!
I think what they're saying is that God breathes and creates air, He shines and creates light, etc.



You alone are the matchless King
To You alone be all majesty
Your glories and wonders, what tongue can recite?
Your breath is my air, you radiate light
Posted 1/19/2009 10:04 PM by OneFlossyChick Xanga True Member - reply

Visit randy_and_tricia's Xanga Site!
Attempt #1

You alone are the matchless King
To You alone be all majesty
Your glories and wonders, what tongue can recite?
Your kingdom eternal, You shine in the light

Attempt #2

You alone are the matchless King
To You alone be all majesty
Your glories and wonders, what tongue can recite?
We bow down in awe at Your power and might

Those are my feeble attempts. I should probably stick to listening to music, instead of trying to dabble as a lyricist.

~RvL
Posted 1/19/2009 10:22 PM by randy_and_tricia - reply

Visit tbonecats's Xanga Site!
The hardest problems in rewriting this part of the chorus is the emphasis on "air" in the tune and the need to keep parallel structure with "you" in the parts of the verse.

I've never heard of this version of the hymn until today, though the tune of the original hymn is one I enjoyed playing and tweaking in my music theory classes at CU. So it's good to see it's been revived in a more contemporary version.

Technically both parts of that sentence are wrong. God doesn't shine in the light either b/c he *is* light. But care needs to be taken at which word in the middle of the sentence has the focus with the longer note, and of course it has to rhyme. Because of the almost cadence at "air," two shorter thoughts in parallel structure would probably work better, but that's potentially harder to come up with.

Potential rhyming words (homophones not included): Fight, height, kite, light, might, night, quite, right, sight, tight, white

Of that list, "might" is already used twice in the song, "light" used once.

#1
You alone are the matchless King
To You alone be all majesty
Your glories and wonders, what tongue can recite?
Your words formed the earth, your kingdom is light

#2
You alone are the matchless King
To You alone be all majesty
Your glories and wonders, what tongue can recite?
You are the Truth, You are the Light
(to use this version you’d take out the pickup notes, which is actually appropriate because generally we were taught to have words representing God to be on downbeats if possible.)

Those are my first-thing-in-the-morning ideas, I’ll continue to think on this.
Posted 1/20/2009 7:55 AM by tbonecats - reply

Visit ravenwing1's Xanga Site!
I have to say, I like the line as is. Because though God does not "breathe", when Jesus walked among us He did. As I sat and pondered your request and read the lines over and over again, it came to me a quick, one line reminder that Jesus is Man and Divine.

The songwriter wrote it that way for a reason. Who are we to change it?
--R
Posted 1/20/2009 7:57 AM by ravenwing1 - reply

Visit BAS2SB's Xanga Site!
I typically oversimplify so to me the original makes sense.  There is no air without His breath as there is no light without His shine. 
Posted 1/20/2009 9:12 AM by BAS2SB - reply

Visit litgirl1979's Xanga Site!

This is one former English Lit geek's perspective- it is not that God "breathes", but more likely a reference to when he created Adam, ie Gen 2:7,  "Then the LORD God formed man of dust from the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being."

I hope this a)helps clarify a possible meaning, and b)helps you enjoy this hymn even more- I look forward to hearing your thoughts on my theory.

Posted 1/20/2009 10:29 AM by litgirl1979 - reply

Visit OneFlossyChick's Xanga Site!
I'd have to say that I also agree with the last 3 comments. Also, I think it's kind of weird when you change a song that someone else has written. Is that even allowed? I mean, sing it with the right words or just... don't. I'd be upset if someone changed the words to one of my poems just because they didn't understand it or like it.

I mean, I realize that I rewrote it, but in my defense, it was early and I was skimming and thought it was just for clarification purposes.
Posted 1/20/2009 5:42 PM by OneFlossyChick Xanga True Member - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to lordjabez's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in lordjabez's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)